Enclosed combustion units (ECD) also called enclosed combustion devices or enclosed flares are widely used in oil and gas operations to control vent gas VOC and methane emissions. ECDs are a good alternative control device when a vapor recovery unit (VRU) is not feasible for the application. Many operators prefer ECDs over candlestick (open tipped) flares since properly designed and sized ECDs do not have a visible flame, minimize or eliminate any smoke and have a far greater destruction efficiency.

Below is some valuable information regarding regulatory requirements, design considerations and uses of ECDs used in oil and gas production and midstream operations.

Applicable Regulations for ECDs

  • EPA federal NSPS OOOO and OOOOa
  • State environmental regulatory air quality standards and permitting rules.

State Air Permit Considerations – ECDs and Flares

  • Some regulatory agencies require ECDs over flares.
  • ECDs installed for State-only air permits (e.g., non-NSPS OOOO/OOOOa) have fewer requirements for monitoring, record keeping and reporting. ECDs are treated like candlestick (open-tipped) flares in many States.
  • ECDs can be a better option than a candlestick flare for meeting facility permit by rule (PBR) and general air permit VOC limitations.
    • Performance tested ECDs can have destruction efficiency greater than 99%
    • Candlestick flares have a presumed destruction efficiency of 95 to 98% (depending on the State agency).
  • Lower VOC emissions from the ECD can ensure a facility’s emissions are below the PBR and general permit VOC limitations.

NSPS OOOOa Requirements for ECDs

  • Destruction efficiency greater than or equal to 95%
  • Mandatory performance testing for ECDs used for storage tanks and compressor seals as follows:
    • One time manufacturer performance testing (EPA List of Performance Tested Combustion Control Devices) or
    • In-field initial performance testing by operator and after every 60 months of service – only required for models not performance tested by manufacturer
    • NOTE: no testing required for ECDs installed to comply with NSPS OOOO
  • Operate ECD within design parameters (e.g., minimum/maximum flowrate) specified by manufacturer. Follow manufacturer’s written operating instructions, procedures and maintenance schedule
  • Install and operate a continuous burning pilot flame
  • Use a monitoring device that continuously indicates the presence of the pilot flame while emissions are routed to the control device
  • No visible smoking or soot emissions
  • Conduct monthly inspections/tests for:
    • Pilot is lit when vapors are sent to the ECD
    • Visible (smoking) emissions test using EPA Method 22 for ECD exhaust
    • Monthly olfactory, visual and auditory (OVA) inspections for system integrity
  • Use an alarm system for bypasses of control device
  • Storage tanks routed to ECD must have thief hatches equipped with a weighted mechanism or equivalent to ensure that the lid remains properly seated
  • Closed vent system (piping) used must:
    • Have a qualified professional engineer design and certify closed vent system – required by NSPS OOOOa only
    • Route all vent gas from storage tanks to the ECD
    • Conduct initial and annual inspection of tank hatches and closed vent system operating with no detectable emissions (leak free) using EPA Method 21


Destruction Efficiency

Performance tested combustors have been demonstrated to have >99% destruction efficiency based one NSPS OOOO/OOOOa performance testing. Cimarron’s Enclosed Combustion Devices (ECD) have a demonstrated destruction efficiency greater than 99%


Reasons to Use ECDs Instead of Candlestick Flares

  • No exposed flame improves safety and eliminates visible flame to public
  • Typically have greater destruction efficiency than candlestick (open tipped) flares
  • Properly designed and sized ECD’s can eliminate smoking issues


Typical Emission Sources Controlled With ECDs

  • Storage tanks (crude oil, condensate, produced water)
  • Vapor recovery towers (VRTs)
  • Heater treater flash gas
  • Emergency and maintenance depressuring from:
    • Compressor blowdown
    • Facility blowdown
    • Low and high pressure separators


Design Best Practices

  • Understand the process conditions before selecting the combustor. Data on the following needed:
    • Equipment routed to combustor
    • Vent gas operating pressure and temperature
    • Gas flowrates – minimum, maximum and average normal
    • Chemical makeup of gas
    • Pilot gas supply source and pressure
  • Ensure that storage tanks routed to combustors operate in a leak free manner (e.g., no leaking thief hatches) so that all gas is routed to the combustor.
  • Ensure sufficient motive force/pressure to send gas to the combustor
  • Use a flame/detonation arrestors
  • Use a knock-out vessel (scrubber) with liquids transfer pump upstream of combustor to remove free liquids – this will help minimize smoking emissions
  • Use a burner control system connected to company communication for monitoring combustor operation
  • Ensure pilot sufficient for the application. Some State air quality regulations allow sparking devices in lieu of pilot flame – provided the ECD flame is monitored when gas sent to combustor
  • Use some method to ensure the presence of a pilot flame (if used) or presence of flame when gas routed to the combustor


Other Use Options

  • For storage tank applications, consider combining a vapor combustion unit (ECD) with a vapor recovery tower (VRT) and vapor recovery unit (VRU). The ECD can be a backup control device to the VRU.
  • Also, a ECD could be used to control storage tank vent gas from a storage tank that uses a VRT to reduce flash losses.


Cimarron Solutions

Contact Cimarron regarding your needs for vapor combustors. Features of our ECDs include:

  • Five models Manufacturer Performance Tested per NSPS OOOO & OOOOa 60.5413(d)
  • Demonstrated VOC destruction efficiency > 99%
  • Eliminates the need for initial and periodic testing for compliance
  • Solar powered BMS and data logging features
  • Cimarron actuator package for low flow and flameout situation
  • Drip tanks for free liquid removal
  • User friendly and easy installation


Contact Cimarron at +1 (844) 746-1676sales@cimarron.com.

Posted Under: Blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *